Holiday Gifts for Teacher Under $25 (2026)
Finding holiday gifts for teacher under $25 is easier with a shortlist. These 11 picks come from 5 direct-to-consumer brands we've researched, with live prices and links straight to each store. Prices run from $8 to $24.99. Our top picks are the Oatmeal “Scotchies” – Butterscotch, Oats & Cinnamon Cookies | Operation Cookies, the Lemon Cookies – Real Lemon Zest & White Chocolate | Operation Cookies and the Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookies – Soft, Chewy & Fresh | Operation Cookies. Read the one-line reason under each pick to find the one that fits them best.
Updated 2026-10-08. Prices sync from each store. We may earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you.
Quick picks
- Oatmeal “Scotchies” – Butterscotch, Oats & Cinnamon Cookies |… Operation Cookies · $24.99–$96.99
- Lemon Cookies – Real Lemon Zest & White Chocolate | Operation Cookies Operation Cookies · $24.99–$96.99
- Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookies – Soft, Chewy & Fresh | Operation… Operation Cookies · $22.99–$85.99
- Kimaka Cowhorn "Joy" Angel Ornament Amaka Africa · $10
- Kimaka Cowhorn "Hope" Star Ornament Amaka Africa · $10
- Mama Mzungu All Natural Handmade Soap - Guest Size Sampler Pack Amaka Africa · $8
- Ancient Column Pen Holder Roomtery · $12.99
- Matisse, the essence of line Tote bag Galartsy · $24
Oatmeal “Scotchies” – Butterscotch, Oats & Cinnamon Cookies | Operation Cookies
$24.99–$96.99
Butterscotch oatmeal cookies with cinnamon, a cozy homemade-style treat to send as a thank-you.
Shop now at Operation Cookies →
Lemon Cookies – Real Lemon Zest & White Chocolate | Operation Cookies
$24.99–$96.99
Lemon cookies made with real zest and white chocolate, a bright treat to brighten someone's day.
Shop now at Operation Cookies →
Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookies – Soft, Chewy & Fresh | Operation Cookies
$22.99–$85.99
Soft, chewy oatmeal chocolate chip cookies that make a comforting treat to send someone.
Shop now at Operation Cookies →
Kimaka Cowhorn "Joy" Angel Ornament
$10
A Joy angel ornament crafted from upcycled cow horn, a small handmade keepsake for the tree.
Shop now at Amaka Africa →
Kimaka Cowhorn "Hope" Star Ornament
$10
A Hope star ornament handcrafted from upcycled cow horn, an easy small gift with a story behind it.
Shop now at Amaka Africa →
Mama Mzungu All Natural Handmade Soap - Guest Size Sampler Pack
$8
A sampler of guest-size handmade vegan soaps made with coconut oil and shea butter, an easy small treat.
Shop now at Amaka Africa →
Ancient Column Pen Holder
$12.99
A pen holder styled like a weathered Greco-Roman column brings a classical touch to a desk or study space.
Shop now at Roomtery →
Matisse, the essence of line Tote bag
$24 · $35 −31%
A canvas tote printed with Matisse's line work is an affordable everyday bag for someone who loves modern art.
Shop now at Galartsy →
Art history rubik's cubes
$22–$119 · $154 −86%
Puzzle cubes printed with works by seven different artists, a playful mix of art history and brain teaser.
Shop now at Galartsy →
Candle-Mulled Cider
$16.99
A mulled cider scented candle with up to 80 hours of burn time fills a home with cozy fall fragrance.
Shop now at Foxcreek Baskets →
Candle-Blueberry poundcake
$16.99
A blueberry poundcake scented candle with up to 80 hours of burn time that fills a room with a bakery aroma.
Shop now at Foxcreek Baskets →